Quantcast
Red's Army

Sorry Olbermann & Henderson, Bird’s play is still the best ever

John - Red's Army (@RedsArmy_John) September 23, 2013 Celtics News 13 Comments

The past few days have been full of some fun surprises.  First, Gerald Henderson took a minute to shoot back a rebuttal to my calling Larry Bird’s steal against the Pistons in 1987 “The best play in Celtics history

Then Keith Olbermann decided he wanted to disagree with me too.  He said John Havlicek’s steal in 1965 was the best.

While all three were great plays that can lay claim to the top spot, I’m going to stick to my original assertion that Bird’s play was better.

Why it’s better than “Havlicek Stole the Ball!”

It was a great play, no doubt.  And it comes with a CLASSIC Johnny Most exultation.

“Havlicek stole the ball!”

While it might be the most famous call in Celtics history, it’s not quite better than Bird’s.

First, the Celtics had the lead.  There’s no telling what could have happened with those last five seconds.  Sure, Keith Olbermann had a point when he said the Celtics would have been eliminated IF Wilt Chamberlain got the ball and dunked it.  That doesn’t take into account the best shot blocker in NBA history, Bill Russell, who was still in the game, and still defending Wilt.

If Havlicek didn’t steal it, a Russell block of Wilt is as conceivable a scenario as a Wilt dunk.  If Havlicek didn’t steal it, Philadelphia still could have missed a shot or turned the ball over.

It did help clinch a Game 7 in the Eastern Conference Finals, which did send the Celtics to the NBA Finals where they beat the Lakers and won their seventh straight title.  If we’re ranking these plays, it’s riiiiiiiiiiight there with the other two.  But it doesn’t surpass them.

Why it’s better than Henderson’s steal

Henderson’s steal was great.  It came in Game 2 of the 1984 NBA Finals and it saved the C’s from going down 2-0 to the Lakers.  Magic Johnson, in perhaps his greatest Finals failure, never got a shot off after Henderson tied it, and the Celtics would win in OT.

But if we’re being nit-picky (and yes, this is very nit-picky, but we’re looking to break a tie here, so that’s what has to happen), Henderson stole a lazy, cross-court lob pass while the Celtics were in a full-court press.  I don’t know why Worthy never gave the ball back to Magic, who broke free of Larry Bird and Kevin McHale after giving the ball up.

Stupid play by Worthy, but still, a great defensive play by Henderson to see it coming and not only steal it, but lay it up too.  Still, that only tied the game, and the Lakers had the ball with a chance to win.  It took a brain-fart by one of the greatest players in NBA history to send it to OT, and then the Celtics needed to out-perform the Lakers for five more minutes to take Game 2.

Bird’s play, however, has things these two plays don’t:

1:  The Celtics were down one with five seconds left and about to go down 3-2 in the ECF to the Pistons.  His play turned a loss into a win as opposed to tying the game up or protecting a lead.

2:  He made up for someone’s mistake in a blink.  He left the guy he was guarding on the right elbow to rush to the un-guarded guy on the left block.  The Celtics were woefully out of position, but he covered everyone’s ass.

3:  He controlled the ball, unlike Havlicek.  Unlike Henderson, who had a clear lane for his own layup (there was a late attempt to contest by Worthy, but he was mostly in the clear), Bird had to spin and find the man cutting to the hoop… which he did… while off-balance and somehow staying in-bounds… and the pass was perfect.

As an added cherry on top of this best play sundae, it came with its own iconic Johnny Most call

“aaaaand… there’s a steal by Bird, underneath to DJ and he lays it in!”

On top of it, you have the amazing reaction shots of Bill Walton and DJ calling Bird over to hug him for being so great.

I don’t want to belittle these other players or plays.  You are well within your rights, Gerald and Keith, to argue for them to be the best ever.  And trust me, I’m happy that you’ve both participated in this debate.

But the fact still remains that Bird’s play was better than both, if by just a smidge.  On my scorecard, it remains the best play in Celtics history.

Like this Article? Share it!

  • Bobby Roberts

    Henderson can’t say his play is the best Celtics play of all-time. He can agree when someone else says it, but he can’t be the loudest voice on that side of the debate.

  • Curt Hays

    I guess I should be mad that Hondo prevented Bill from having the greatest block in Celtics history.

  • Curt Hays

    Damn, I love the Celtics.

  • 33 better than 23

    Henderson’s steal was 1984, not 1987. The Celtics lose that series if Henderson doesn’t make the steal and layup. Bird’s steal did not lead to a championship. We measure by banners in Boston. Henderson’s steal is the greatest.

  • KGino

    If my memory is correct, didn’t bird turn the ball over before making that steal? Thus covering his own ass as well

    • 33 better than 23

      Rodman blocked Bird’s shot, then the ball went out of bounds off Sichting’s leg

  • Tommy_Heinsohn

    The greatest play in Celtics history:

    Nah, but really IMO it’s Havlicek. Good debate though.

    • KGino

      This was the play that robbed the Boshtrich of his manhood, making him the flamboyant homosexual raptor he is today

  • Joey

    Jeff Green is the greatest Celtic of all time.

  • Luke Walton

    Better steal and overall play. Bird. More impactful steal? Henderson. Bird’s steal just meant we had to go to the finals and get our asses kicked by the lakers. Henderson’s steal allowed us to beat the lakers. Any questions?

  • Luke Walton

    Now, regarding the best play in celtics history. It’s none of these things. In fact, I’d have to spend some time thinking about it. In the meantime, scroll ahead to 1:32:12 on this vid and watch my dad earn a nomination in this category.

    • 33 better than 23

      I’d take that ’86 Celtics team over any other team in NBA history. Bird was at his absolute peak, but the addition of Bill Walton was what made them special. Someday soon, #5 will go in the rafters for KG – us old timers will always remember Big Bill in addition to Garnett.

  • Pingback: Reigniting a decades old debate | Thuzio Blog | News & Updates | Book an Athlete